Pras on WorldFilms: Michael Moore’s WHERE TO INVADE NEXT

Sarcastic, Hilarious, Educational  And As Always, (Almost) Guaranteed To Make You Feel Shitty About The System That Exists In United States. “WHERE TO INVADE NEXT” finds Moore traveling to foreign countries, mainly in Europe, to claim their best civic ideas for America.

Where to Invade NextMichael Moore spent the first decade of the twenty-first century chronicling modern America at its worst: School shootings; a broken healthcare system; a berserk economy built on unregulated greed; and, most controversially, the Bush administration’s response to 9/11. It has been six years since Moore’s last big-screen documentary, “Capitalism: A Love Story,” and violence, injustice, and political cowardice are still everyday staples of American life.

As I walked in at this evening’s screening, I wondered if the new Michael Moore film was an anti-war message, or whether it was an indictment of America’s defense policies.   Michael Moore had taken them on already in the Cannes Palme d’Or winning Fahrenheit 9/11 back in 2004. He also took on the American healthcare system with his Oscar nominated film Sicko in 2007. He even took on gun violence and America’s obsession with guns back in 2002 with the Oscar & Cannes Palme d’Or winning film Bowling For Columbine.

His groundbreaking film ofcourse was the 1990 film  Roger & Me, a statement on corporate greed targeting General Motors  and how it bankrupted and destroyed his beloved home town of Flint, Michigan, a town in the news again about its suffering a massive drinking water contamination crisis  (the film was now used as subject material for many business school courses, including mine).

where-to-invade-next-20158197

This time around in the new film WHERE TO INVADE NEXT, Michael Moore trains his inimitable style of sarcasm and hilarious storytelling on the American education system, the American penal system, the deep social inequality and how America created a system built on white-washing our past history to showcase itself as the model system of national governance and economic management to the world, all at once. Now in his 60s, Moore has, in fact, transformed into a self-described “crazy optimist.”

To learn what the USA can learn from other nations, this time Michael Moore assumes the role of a self-appointed globetrotting “invader” on behalf of a much-troubled America to see what they have to offer. All that was missing was a cameo appearance by Bernie Sanders.

where_to_invade_next__2015_3557

Moore visits Italy to learn about how Italian companies allow their workers enjoys vacation days and worker pay that would unimaginable here, yet enjoys higher worker morale, productivity and prosperity that their American counterparts. Interesting visits to Ducati’s factory and interviews assembly line workers, and those at a high-fashion apparel house.

This image provided by Dog Eat Dog Films shows director Michael Moore, left, and Claudio Domenicali, CEO of Ducati, in a scene from his documentary, "Where to Invade Next." The movie opens in U.S. theaters on Feb. 12, 2016. (Dog Eat Dog Films via AP)

This image provided by Dog Eat Dog Films shows director Michael Moore, left, and Claudio Domenicali, CEO of Ducati, in a scene from his documentary, “Where to Invade Next.” The movie opens in U.S. theaters on Feb. 12, 2016. (Dog Eat Dog Films via AP)

In France Moore takes us on a visit to the public school system, the teaching system, the healthier school lunches served in French schools and  best of their no-homework policy.

In Slovenia, where a college education is free, he talks with American students and teachers who left America and moved here. They highlight why this system works better than America’s college system designed to load students with a lifelong burden of debt. He even gets a 45-minute private meeting with Borut Pahor, the sitting President of Slovenia.

In Germany we visit Faber-Castell, the famed maker of specialized pencils and drawing tools for schools and design work. In a digital age where use of paper is fast being replaced by the computer screen, Faber Castell has had its best year ever in productivity and worker morale.

Next we visit Portugal and meet with their head of drugs enforcement agency to understand why the country has the lowest incidence of drug-related offenses in a society that has decriminalized every kind of drug well beyond marijuana.

It’s the prison part of the film that proves to be especially insightful, with Moore learning that most developed countries outside of North America view prison as a means of rehabilitation rather than pure punishment.  Norway becomes his argument about a model penal system works and how its humane treatment of prisoners focus on human dignity and reformation and brings social benefits. He takes us inside two different prisons and chats with prisoners who live like free people, and administrative staff carries no weapons. Dehumanization is something that’s simply not acceptable in places like a Norweigian super-max prison where inmates start their sentence by watching a pop sing-along music video cover of “We Are the World” made by the guards

1where_to_invade_next

As for Tunisia, the country that touched off the Arab Spring, Moore finds democratic passion not only still thriving there but actually achieving worthwhile results. On his only non-European stopover, Moore also takes time to interview a Tunisian activist who cannot understand why Americans know so little about the rest of the world, when the rest of the world knows so much about them. Tunisia where government funded healthcare services for women works better than most advanced countries. It was amazing to observe how women power and public opinion brought down a dictatorship and replaced with a deeply conservative Islamic government which also was forced to give in to changes in its anti-women policies.2where_to_invade_next__2015_1974

Perhaps the most incisive and insightful segment was his visit Iceland where he shows how a country that was almost destroyed by the economic fallout from the 2008 mortgage crisis clawed its way back to health and became prosperous again.We also discover an educational system that not only turned itself around from being one of the worst in the world to being quite possibly the best, but also one that includes such foreign-to-the-U.S. novelties as shorter school days, minimal homework, and no private schools, thus forcing rich and poor to inhabit the same spaces. Its also a country that has served a s a model for women-led politics and business. In feminist Iceland, even more fascinating than the fact that the nation elected one of the world’s first female president, Vigdís Finnbogadóttir, in 1980, is that the one bank that didn’t fall during their recent financial crisis had three women as part of its board of directors, thus leading to a discussion on how having more women in power led to diversity in views and leading to less risky business behaviour.

Where

Whether it’s serving tasty and nutritious school lunches or offering quality college education for free, these countries have found a way to do something meaningful. There are hilarious shot of the Italian couple’s astonishment when they’re told that Americans have no legally required paid vacation, or a quote from the French chef about how he’s never eaten a hamburger. The results might seem Utopian but in fact are based on practical realities.

Many of the ideas on display here seem relatively easy for the U.S. to implement, as Moore states earlier on, with the catch being that income taxes would have to increase for the wealthy. However, he makes the point that with things like medicare, free tuition, more vacation-time and more, citizens would actually wind-up wasting far less of their income on things that are considered a human right in places like Italy, Norway, France and more.

The final message of the film highlights the irony that most of the ideas he had been searching for Moore’s films have originally been American ideas. All the game-changing notions of other nations, the film notes in a wry postscript, began in the U.S. His big reveal is that Americans used to be much more caring toward one another, and that was reflected in the values we championed and the politics we practiced. How Did We Lose Ourselves? How Do We Get The Magic Back?

Michael Moore’s been among the most lucrative documentaries at the box office. His “Fahrenheit 9/11” earned $119.2 million in 2004; his last film, 2009’s “Capitalism: A Love Story,” made $14.4 million.

Pras On World Films: BIENVENUE CHEZ LES CH’TIS (“Welcome To The Sticks” / FRANCE 2008)

BIENVENUE CHEZ LES CH’TIS (Welcome to the Sticks or Welcome to the Land of Shtis) is a 2008 French comedy film starring Kad Merad, Dany Boon and Zoé Félix. A man born and raised on France’s Southern coast is exiled to the Northern territories in this comedy from actor, director and screenwriter Dany Boon.The film broke nearly every box office record in France: it debuted as the top film at 793 sites. As of 28 February 2010, the film had been seen by 20.5 million people in 23 weeks, thereby breaking the long-standing record held by 1966’s La Grande Vadrouille (17.27 million admissions). The film has grossed US$192,928,551 in the box-office in France alone.

Philippe Abrams (Kad Merad) is the manager of the postal service (La Poste) in Salon-de-Provence, Bouches-du-Rhône, in southern France. He is married to Julie (Zoe Felix), whose depressive nature makes his life impossible. She has been down in the dumps. At the constant urging of his wife, has long been lobbying for a transfer to one of the much-coveted positions in the more glamorous surroundings of Côte d’Azur,  he thinks would be one way to lift her spirits. As this favourable position will be granted to somebody who is disabled, Abrams decides to pretend that he is. However, Philippe’s attempts to finagle a transfer (by pretending that he is handicapped) fail. The management finds out. When the ruse is discovered, he ends up instead, being transferred to Bergues,  as punishment with a forced relocation.

Bergues is a village in Northern France that lies stuck between Belgium and the English Channel, near Dunkirk in northern France – and the Nord-Pas-de-Calais region in particular. For years the northern region, Nord-Pas de Calais, has been stereotyped as a miserable hell of disused coal mines and rusting factories, where alcoholic, unemployed or suicidal inhabitants keep warm by beating each other up or gorging on chips with vinegar. The British might think of Calais as a bounteous land of booze cruises and Channel tunnel coach tours, but in France it’s grim up north. These depressed and rain-soaked northerners, nicknamed Ch’tis, spoke an indecipherable patois, Ch’timi, and were thought to have changed little since Emile Zola captured their bleak existence in his 19th century mining novel, Germinal. It is considered “the sticks” – a cold and rainy place inhabited by unsophisticated ch’tis who speak a strange language called “ch’ti” in local parlance, and “cheutimi” in the South (In this area, the indigenes speak a language known as Picard – an amalgam of French, Flemish and Latin).

Scene from Bienvenue chez les Ch'tis

For the Abrams, very prejudiced southerners, the North is a nightmare, a freezing region, inhabited by uncouth beings, spluttering out an incomprehensible language. Philippe essentially perceives the region as the “Siberia of France.” Judging by the grim look on his wife’s face, one would suspect that Philippe was being sent to the front-lines, never to return, when he says goodbye to her and his young son. Philippe goes alone.  With misery in his heart, he dons extreme winter clothing and trudges off to his new post, saying goodbye to Julie and their son, who opt to stay behind. On the motorway Philippe is stopped by a policeman for travelling too slowly, but when he hears about the driver’s final destination he can only offer his commiserations and wave him on his lonely way.  To make matters worse, not long after arriving in Bergues, Philippe nearly runs over a man while driving home drunk — who turns out to be one of his new colleagues at the post office. He has to spend his first night at Antoine’s place – Antoine is one of his co-workers. First Philippe dislikes Antoine for his rudeness and because he thinks Antoine is gay (actually, he found photographs of Antoine dressed as a woman, but they were taken during a carnival party).

To his great surprise, he discovers Bergues a charming place, a warm bunch and welcoming people.  After a rocky start in which Philippe finds himself knee-deep in misunderstandings and struggling to grasp the area’s unique dialect, he soon finds his bearings and is given a warm welcome by his fellow post office employees. These include Antoine (Boon himself), the postman and village bell-ringer, who struggles to escape his overbearing mother’s grip and is deeply infatuated with Annabelle (Anne Marivin), often drowning his sorrows on the job when she rebuffs his advances. Philippe begins to love the community and its people, even growing infatuated with Annabelle (Anne Marivin), a beautiful letter carrier. In helping to straighten out various characters’ little problems, Philippe becomes a contented member of the Bergues community. Soon, he is completely won over, eating smelly Maroilles cheese; talking to virtually every local (by delivering their mail, and accepting the recipient’s invitation for a drink); playing at the beach; playing the bells at the bell tower together, drinking beer like a local, going to an RC Lens football match and so forth.  Finally, he becomes best friends with  Antoine.

But for some reason he feels compelled to maintain an unhappy façade in front of his friends and family back home, regaling them with horror stories on his weekend visits.

When Philippe returns to Salon over the weekend he tries to describe the happy turn of events to his wife who has remained in the South with their young son, but  Julie refuses to believe that he likes it in the North. She even thinks that he is lying so as not to upset her. This inspires Philippe to tell her what she wants to believe: that his life is wretched there.   Inevitably, these tall tales come back to haunt him when his wife (Zoé Félix) decides it is her duty to stand by her man in this hellhole. She decides to join him in the North to relieve his gloom. Philippe must either tell the truth, or keep deceiving her. He is also forced to confess to his new friends and colleagues that he has described them as barbarians to his wife. First, they are angry, but they then decide to help him by behaving as such to cover for his lies and to scare Julie so she will depart quickly. Also they let her stay in the old mining place of Bergues, pretending it is the main town. Julie has a very bad weekend. Just when she’s ready to go back south, she discovers that she has been tricked when a local biker tells Julie that the actual town of Bergues is several kilometers away. When Philippe finds Julie at his real Bergues home, he tells her the truth about the happiness and friendship that the town has brought him. Julie is disappointed at first, but after realising her husband is happy, she decides ultimately to move to Bergues to stay with Phillipe, to be supportive.

Bienvenue chez les Ch'tis

Meanwhile, Antoine and Annabelle who had been dating for over a year, but had broken up due to Antoine’s passiveness towards his mother still nurse hopes for their relationship. Anne Marivin, charmante comédienne, remarquée depuis le succès de Despite their split, Antoine still has feelings for Annabelle, who now has a new boyfriend. Upon learning this, Antoine cheers himself up by drinking alcohol during his work hours and behaves in an erratic manner. When Phillipe urges Antoine to take courage and be assertive, Antoine finally confesses to his mother that he loves Annabelle and is planning to move to a new place with her. Unexpectedly, his mother is happy about it – she has waited all these years for Antoine to stand up for himself. As a result, Antoine proposes to Annabelle by the bell tower when it is playing a Stevie Wonder song. Annabelle accepts, and they get married.

Three years later, Phillipe receives a transfer to move south. Accepting the offer, Phillipe and his family move south. Just as he is about to say goodbye, he is reduced to tears, proving Antoine’s theory on the Ch’tis proverb (“A visitor brays [cries] twice up north: once on his arrival and once at his departure.”)

When it was released in February of this year, Bienvenue chez les Ch’tis became an instant smash among French cinemagoers, and has subsequently roared towards the decade-long box-office crown that James Cameron’s Titanic has held in that country. Despite even viewers from Marseille and even Normandy admitting they can’t follow parts of the Ch’timi dialogue – a mixture of the Picard dialect of early French with the odd bit of Flemish – ticket sales for this film have been phenomenal.

Bienvenue chez les Ch’tis is based around the perception that life in the south of France is nothing much gorgeous sunshine and happiness, while the north of the country is a cold and miserable place to be; but Boon, a native of Nord-Pas de Calais, wants to show us that things aren’t as grim up north as many might think. One can see why Pathé (the producers) feared this might not fly at the local US multiplex. How could people be expected to laugh at intricate misapprehensions of a language they don’t even understand? But there is no problem whatsoever, such is the ingenuity of the writing, the fluency and comic timing of the actors, and in particular the assured direction of Dany Boon, who happens to be a Ch’ti himself. Such a success can only be attributed to the way Dany Boon’s film touches upon national stereotypes and prejudices. Such a scenario inevitably doesn’t hold as much resonance for viewers outside of France, but Bienvenue chez les Ch’tis possesses a warm sense of humour that should translate for most audiences.

There are two or three hilarious sequences in Bienvenue chez les Ch’tis. One occurs early on when Philippe’s attempt to play his non-existent disabled card descend into slapstick; another sees Philippe and Antoine cycling haphazardly around Bergues while growing increasingly inebriated; and the big set-piece in which the whole town try to convince Philippe’s wife that life here is every bit as horrific as she’s heard is very funny indeed. Aside from those instances, however, the comedy in this picture is of a determinedly gentle variety, and while it’s far from unappealing it isn’t quite amusing enough to distract from the film’s laziness in other areas.

The subtitler succeeds in matching French mis-speaks with plausible English equivalents in a tour de force which merits the creation of a whole new Oscar category and provides Bienvenue chez les Ch'tisBritish audiences (insofar as there are any) with an extra layer of entertainment denied to their francophone counterparts. The opening scenes seem to set us up for a classic farce, and I greatly enjoyed Philippe’s first encounter with Antoine, in which both sexual and linguistic confusion come into play. The linguistic element of the film is particularly important. The Ch’ti of the title refers both to the natives of Bergues and their distinctive patois, where the letter “s” is pronounced “ch”, and numerous words find their meaning completely warped. The film’s subtitlers have obviously endeavoured to retain this core component of Bienvenue chez les Ch’tis’ humour (office is confused with fish, for example), and the potentially parochial gags Boon likes to trade in come across remarkably well. The film has already been sold in Canada, where it is expected to appeal to the equally stereotype-laden Québécois, as well as in Belgium and Switzerland. “We knew it would be popular but we didn’t expect it to reach this level,” said a publicist for the film.

The acting is very strong across the board, with Boon being a dab hand at playing the likable dolt (as he showed in Patrice Leconte’s My Best Friend), and he is assisted by particularly strong work from both Merad and the heart-stoppingly beautiful Marivin.

The film’s writer, director and co-star, the popular comedian Dany Boon, is a proud Ch’ti and son of an Algerian truck driver and a French cleaner. He has succeeded in turning around the French cinematic cliché that romping comedies take place in the south, usually on a beach, and the north is reserved for depressing social realism. He said: “I wanted to make a very human comedy where the main character, an outsider, discovers the Ch’timi culture and warmth … summed up in the proverb: ‘An outsider who comes to the north cries twice, once when he arrives, and once when he leaves’.”

“Bienvenue Chez les Ch’tis” (“Welcome to the Sticks”), has been attracting filmgoers in astounding numbers. The movie has sold close to 19 million tickets in a country of 65 million people, and is on course to overtake the all-time domestic record of 20.7 million set by “Titanic.” Made for $17 million, “Bienvenue” has had sales of about $185 million so far. Local politicians came to blows over funding of the film when the Nord-Pas-de-Calais regional council contributed €600,000 to the €11m (£8.4m) budget and local communists objected. But after its premiere in the north, with the publication of Ch’ti phrase books, the region is expecting a tourism boom. Bergues, the town of 4,000 people where the film is set and where the cinema closed more than 20 years ago, is at the centre of a Ch’ti craze. Within a few weeks, “Bienvenue” had turned into a bona fide grass-roots phenomenon: Sales of Maroilles and the local Ch’ti beer have skyrocketed; busloads of tourists swarm Bergues, the town where the action takes place. Suddenly, every French person had an inner Ch’ti.”People have started driving here specially to have their wedding pictures taken in front of the belfry or the post office. We’re thinking of producing a special commemoration envelope,” said Jacques Martel, one of the deputy mayors. “There is a major effect on tourism and hopefully on stereotypes too. Humour is a weapon.”

PRODUCTION CREDITS

DirectorDany Boon  /  ScreenplayDany Boon

ScreenplayFranck Magnier

Executive ProducerEric Hubert

ACTING CREDITS

Kad Merad – Philippe Abrams
Dany Boon – Antoine Bailleul
Zoe Felix – Julie Abrams
Philippe Duquesne – Fabrice Canoli
Jacques BonnaffeLine Renaud – Madame Bailleul
Stephane Freiss – Jean Sabrier, Philippe’s Superior
Michel Galabru – Julie’s Great-Uncle
Anne Marivin – Annabelle Deconninck
Guy Lecluyse – Yann Vandernoout
Patrick Bosso – Policeman ‘A7’
Zinedine Soualem – Momo
Jerome Commandeur – Inspector Lebic
Christophe Rossignon – Brasserie Waiter
Yael Boon – Angry Post Office Customer
Alexandre Carriere – Tony
Lorenzo Ausilia Foret – Raphael Abrams
Fred Personne – Monsieur Vasseur
Franck Andrieux – Monsieur Leborgne
Jean-Christophe Herbeth – Monsieur Mahieux
Jean-Pierre Picotin – Monsieur Tizaute
Jenny Cleve – Grandma ‘Quinquin’
Claude Talpaert – Grandpa Quinquin
Sylviane Goudal – Post Office Customer
Maryline Delbarre – Martine de Momo
Guillaume Morand – Old colleague of Phillipe’s
Yann Konigsberg – Jean’s Salon Colleague 2
Nadege Beausson-Diagne – Salon Employee
Jean-Francois Elberg – Service Station Employee
Eric Bleuze – Man on Moped
Bruno Tuchszer – Bergues Policeman 1
Mickael Angele – Bar Owner in Mining Town
Patrick Cohen – Customer Thrown Out of Bar
Louisette Douchin – Woman with Mussels
Jean-Marc Vauthier – Miner
Cedric Magyari – Miner
Theo Behague – Local Child
Mathieu Sophys – Local Child
Laetitia Maisonhaute – Jean’s Secretary